130,500 causes · $320M raised · 4.7 since 2009
Deductibility and the recipient
The sentence almost every benefit fund gets wrong, in the first hour.
Free for up to 20 items Unlimited bidders No credit card required
The general position
A charitable contribution is a gift to a qualifying organization that controls how the money is used. Money raised for a specific named individual or family is generally a personal gift instead — because the donor has directed it to a person, and no charity has discretion over it.
That holds regardless of how sympathetic the situation is, who is collecting, or whether a charity's name appears anywhere on the page. The determining question is who controls the funds and whether the recipient was earmarked.
What that means in practice
- Do not write "tax deductible" on a fund for a named person
- Do not issue receipts that look charitable, or use another organization's EIN because somebody offered it
- Do not let a business advertise a percentage night as a charitable donation without checking
- Do say what is true: this is a community benefit fund for a named family, contributions are personal gifts, and donors should not claim them
Organizers worry that saying this will reduce giving. It does not — people giving to a fallen firefighter's family are not making a tax decision — and the alternative is a large number of people having been told something untrue by somebody they trusted.
If deductibility matters, route it properly
It can be done, and in public safety there is usually an existing structure designed for exactly this.
- A departmental or association benevolent fund, which may be a qualifying charity with an established process for assisting members
- A union or professional association relief fund
- A national responder charity — several exist specifically to support line-of-duty families and can receive gifts and grant assistance properly
- A community foundation, which can frequently establish a fund quickly and administer it correctly
The trade is real and worth stating: a qualifying charity must retain discretion over the funds, which means it decides how assistance is given rather than simply passing everything to a named family. Organizers should understand that before choosing the route, and the family should too.
Both routes are legitimate
A direct community fund for a named family is a perfectly proper thing to run. It is simply not a charitable donation, and the page should say so.
Choose deliberately in hour one, tell donors accurately, and do not switch framing halfway through — which is how funds end up with two different descriptions circulating and neither of them trusted.
Other things that come up fast
- Gift tax — large personal gifts have their own rules and this is a question for an adviser rather than a committee
- Benefits and eligibility — a large lump sum can affect a family's eligibility for other assistance, which is worth them knowing before the money arrives
- Who holds the account — an individual holding a large sum on somebody's behalf carries personal exposure and should not be doing it informally
- Platform fees and processing — disclose them; donors are reasonable about fees and unreasonable about discovering them
The eligibility point is easy to miss and genuinely important. A family receiving a large sum may find it interacts with other support they rely on, and somebody should raise that with them early rather than after.
Get advice, quickly, even though everything is urgent
One conversation with an accountant or attorney in the first days is worth more than any amount of careful wording afterwards, and in a public safety context somebody in the department's network will usually do it at no charge if asked.
General information, not legal or tax advice. Whether a payment is deductible, and what happens to money raised for a named individual, is fact-specific and consequential — this is a situation to put in front of an adviser quickly, even when everything is urgent.
More guides for First Responder Funds
Frequently asked questions
Why is a gift to a named family not deductible?
A charitable contribution is a gift to a qualifying organization that controls how the money is used. Money directed to a specific person is a personal gift, because no charity has discretion over it — regardless of how sympathetic the situation or who is collecting.
How can we make donations deductible?
Route them through a structure designed for it: a departmental or association benevolent fund, a union relief fund, a national responder charity, or a community foundation. The trade is that the charity must retain discretion over the funds rather than passing everything to a named family.
Is a direct community fund still legitimate?
Entirely. It is simply not a charitable donation, and the page should say so. Choose deliberately in hour one and do not switch framing halfway through.
What else should the family know early?
That a large lump sum can interact with their eligibility for other assistance. It is easy to miss and genuinely important, and somebody should raise it before the money arrives rather than after.
Ready to start your auction?
Name it now and set it up later. Free for up to 20 items, unlimited bidders, no credit card.
Free for up to 20 items · Unlimited bidders · No credit card required